A healthy diet for prediabetes explores the different options, the various philosophies about starches and the role of dietary fat in weight loss; and the power of walking to lower blood glucose.
The diagnosis of prediabetes is the first difficulty. Many have normal fasting blood glucose and an unremarkable HbA1c test; yet their levels soar after a starchy meal. Unknown to both themselves and their doctors they are at risk of progressing to T2D; so there is no emphasis on the importance of a healthy diet.
They have what is now being called "intermediate hyperglycemia;" frequently undetected seriously raised blood-glucose after sweet and starchy meals.
The Diabetes Federation is now recommending the 1-hour 75g glucose tolerance test as the best way to identify these high risk individuals who fall under the radar of the more usual screening methods[1]. This is the opinion of a 22 member international expert panel; it's not to be taken lightly or summarily dismissed.
"Should the plasma glucose rise above 8.6 mmol/L (155 mg/dL) one hour after the sweet drink they have intermediate hyperglycemia."
There are many different opinions and philosophies as to what constitutes a healthy diet for prediabetes. They are conflicting and contradictory; as usual, consumer beware.
The first opinion is that all carbs are bad; period. Avoid them if you are prediabetic; and even more so if you have the frank disease. You should be eating less than 20 grams of starch per day.
Many but certainly not all supporters of the ketogenic diets hold to this view. That would mean no whole grains nor any legumes.
There is a subset of the ketogenic folk who would disagree. In their opinion it's the refined carbs that are bad. So they would insist that whole grains and legumes are absolutely fine; as are new potatoes which have a large amount of resistant starch. Nevertheless the overall glycemic load should be limited; small helpings.
However let's acknowledge that true whole grains are not easy to come by.
The "big fat lie" internationally allows millers to label their flour as whole grain, provided they have not extracted more than 40% of the goodies; the germ and bran.
The germ contains the very important fats that amongst many other factors supply satiety. The management of hunger is central to prediabetes.
The fibre slows gastric emptying; that is also so important in the management of prediabetes.
Prediabetes and obesity go hand in glove; strictly limiting the fat in a healthy diet for prediabetes is absolutely essential. Is that true?
No it's the saturated fats that contribute to the complications of diabetes; we should strictly limit all dairy products, red meat and even eggs. Is that true?
No we disagree; it's the seed oils that are highly inflammatory and contribute to the heart disease associated with prediabetes.
You're all wrong. It is ever since Ancyl Keys in the late 1970s clearly cooked the books that prediabetes accelerated; he recommended we eschew animal fat and get our calories from carbs instead.
Ten years later the prevalence of diabetes took off; and is still rocketing into the stratosphere.
The long and the short of it is that there is simply no consensus as to what makes up a healthy diet for prediabetes.
There is universal agreement that avocados and olive oil are healthy fats. Hummus would be questioned by some followers of the ketogenic diets; made from chickpeas it does have some resistant starch.
The golden rule for prediabetes is that there is another way to limit the response of serum glucose to dietary starch. A short brisk ten-minute walk changes everything. The sugars entering the portal blood stream from the carbs we have just eaten are turned instead into glycogen in the liver to supply the muscles.
Those who are prediabetic should follow every starchy meal with a short walk.
"Neurologic Disorders are now the top global cause of illness and disability; and diabetic nerve disease is the fastest-growing of all these conditions.
- Lancet Neurology, March 2024
The HbA1c test give the average blood glucose over a two month period; highs from illness, exercise and fasting for example are smoothed out.
The test is more expensive than serum blood glucose tests.
One great difficulty is that 30% of those with a raised HbA1c will have a normal fasting blood glucose; and vice versa.
Even having both tests will still miss about 25% of those with intermediate hyperglycemia; yet they are highly likely to progress to full blown diabetes.
The expert panel is currently saying that a serum glucose value of 8.6 or higher after the 1-hour challenge is now considered the best predictor of whether a person is likely to progress to full blown diabetes.
It gives a firm diagnosis of "intermediate hyperglycemia;" despite the possibility of normal FBG and HbA1c tests.
Those at risk should have a coronary calcium scan; and absolutely avoid supplements containing the mineral.
A healthy diet for prediabetes means limiting carbs, especially those that are refined; and exercising after starchy meals.
A healthy diet for prediabetes absolutely must include strictly limiting sugar to no more than 6 tsp per day together with all refined carbs. Total starch should certainly be less than 100 grams; and far lower for those who are morbidly obese.
It is without a doubt the most difficult rule; and breaking it repeatedly is the cause of the diabetes and obesity pandemics that are sweeping the world.
That means eschewing white rice, commercial bread and cake flour; most pastas, refined corn grits and potatoes from cold storage too.
Those with prediabetes who break rule 1 are at very high risk of progressing to the full blown disease.
"I am resolved; 'tis but a three year fast.
The mind shall banquet, though the body pine.
Fat paunches have lean pates; and dainty bits make rich the ribs but bankrupt quite the wits."
- William Shakespeare, Love's Labour is Lost
Those who have been diagnosed with diabetes will also have to limit even the good healthy carbs like whole grains, legumes and butternut, for example until their 1-hour challenge GTT returns to the region around 8.6 mmol/L (155 mg/dL).
Take a short, brisk walk after every starchy meal.
The old lifestyle that got us into trouble in the first place has to change dramatically. This is not about dieting; it's a permanent whole new way of living. It has to include aerobic exercise after starchy meals.
The new lifestyle can almost be compared with a spiritual conversion. It begins with a new determination to honour our bodies as holy places.
Health in many ways remains pure mystery; but turning to a healthy diet for prediabetes dramatically shifts the statistics in your favour. You are far more likely, yet not guaranteed to be able to enjoy a long and zestful life with little or no medication.
How does your lifestyle rate? If it's good then researchers have found you will have half the risk of Long Covid too.
Regularly enjoying braised new potatoes for example would certainly contribute to a high-quality diet; planting, heaping and harvesting them will provide strengthening exercise.
Current smokers have a dramatically higher risk of going blind; a 12-times greater probability of macular degeneration, for example. There is a 3 fold raised likelihood of glaucoma; and even worse chance of getting cataracts[4].
Two carotenes found abundantly in green leafy vegetables and yellow foods are directed by the body mainly to the eyes; lutein and zeaxanthin. A deficiency is the chief cause of adult-onset macular degeneration, the most common reason for blindness in the elderly.
Smoking, a poor diet and diabetes makes the risk of blindness in old age far higher; game, set and match.
The prediabetes journey will be for each of us unique, though common features will highlight the way we got sick; but had no inkling that it was happening. There has to be a determination not to go from any starchy meal directly to the couch, computer stool or car.
My own journey started with the shock discovery that a glass of freshly-squeezed orange juice shot my blood glucose up to 9.3.
My greatest difficulties were giving up commercial bread, scones and cakes for ever; and taking a brisk walk after dinner. Discovering that natural honey had a low GI softened having to eschew sugar.
The bread story actually reached back into the mists of time; watching college friends mill their own flour and bake their own loaves. Many years later I decided to emulate them and continue to do so to this day.
The result is the most delicious best bread in the whole world, baked with 100% wholemeal flour; using a sourdough starter.
The encouraging news is that with a HbA1c now of 5.4 all anxiety has left; and at 76 both the good wife and I are busy, cheerful and going at life filled with enthusiasm and joy. It will inevitably one day come to an end; but death will have no sting.
But we continue to be diligent.
Here are a few gems from a weight loss conference; some very helpful ideas espoused by top physicians.
"We really want to be much more upstream by thinking of obesity as a biologic disease and learning from cancer; and how it is much more about early screening and detection. Then, if you find something, reversing the biology and make it benign."
- Dr Mike McConnell, Clinical Professor of Medicine, Stanford
You too can get on top of diabetes; it's a monster that will make us utterly miserable and cut our lives short.
A close relative recently had his leg amputated; a friend is going blind from a diabetic retinopathy. This is not "small beer" to quote the bard again.
But it will take a complete change of lifestyle; and a return to eating the food your great-grandmother once served.
To add more protein enjoy chopped chicken, pork or simply plonk an egg to poach on any dinner; legumes for the vegan. The underlying theme is zero refined carbs; no white rice, pasta or cold-storage potatoes ever again; except on "high and holy days." You can break down and have a pancake of Shrove Tuesday; but still take that race after supper.
Desserts too are kept for high and holy days; malva pudding is gone for ever.
Strong research proves that type 2 diabetes can be completely put into remission without the use of any drugs by using food as medicine.
Notice the large amount of fibre in these foods; it's strongly associated with weight loss, improved pancreatic function and better control of blood glucose.
There are so few specific warning signs of prediabetes; that's why it is so dangerous. 80% of those eating typical grocery store food are completely unaware that the Sword of Damocles hangs over their heads.
Are you constantly thirsty? And having to get up several times a night but your urologist declares that your prostate is fine?
Fatigue is a common symptom but it pertains to so many other diseases; it's not specific.
Tingling and numbness especially in the feet should absolutely be taken seriously.
Abdominal obesity is certainly a sign that all is not well in the state of Denmark; the organs are surrounded by and infiltrated with "white fat." It literally squeezes out the islets of Langerhans in your pancreas that secrete insulin.
If 80% of the population is suffering from this serious malady then everyone should have a 1 hour GTT periodically. Take a long walk once the test is over; it's an immense amount of sugar.
If you are prediabetic then damage to kidneys, blood vessels and the heart will be starting; "min dae" to use the South African phrase.
The medical advice is universal and simple; cut out the refined carbs and exercise more. Otherwise life will needlessly be cut short.
When browsing use right click and "Open Link in New Tab" or you may get a bad gateway signal.
"The prevalence of obesity in adults is 40.3%. When expanded to include those who are merely overweight, the figure rises to a sobering 73.6 percent. This means almost 3 out of 4 people in a doctor's waiting room, a shopping mall or the park potentially have metabolic disease."
Our newsletter is entitled "create a cyan zone" at your home, preserving both yourself and Mother Earth for future generations; and the family too, of course. We promise not to spam you with daily emails promoting various products. You may get an occasional nudge to buy one of my books.
Here are the back issues.
Did you find this page interesting? How about forwarding it to a friendly book or food junkie? Better still, a social media tick would help.
Address:
56 Groenekloof Rd,
Hilton, KZN
South Africa
Website:
https://www.bernard-preston.com