Meal planning and carb counting can be very destructive; we recommend instead finding out more about starches and how to prepare them.
You have presumably come to Bernard Preston's site looking for help with meal planning and carb counting. I am trying to get in your head; what is it you are really wanting?
To start off let me share with you my understanding of carbs; and let's get it straight, you will find any number of contradictory and different belief system about starches. Some doctors think you should be avoiding them altogether but really, is that necessary?
First and foremost I believe we all need carbs but we should choose them carefully; they are not all the same. Some are profoundly good for us and should be eaten daily whilst others are horrifically bad and should be avoided at all costs; or least enjoyed only on high and holy days.
The carb counting chart above for diabetics from WebMD, one of my favourite sites, has its uses but I find it grossly oversimplified and misleading. Is an apple the same as a tablespoon of syrup? True, they both contain 15 grams, will break down to glucose and be absorbed into the portal blood stream but that's where the similarity ends; chalk and cheese.
Enjoy an apple by all means but absolutely avoid the syrup; both have 15 grams of carbohydrate.
It is absolutely true that we must have protein and fats, or be stunted and die but there is no absolute need for carbs; the body is able to get energy from the former. Nevertheless there is simply masses of research that apples, whole grains and legumes are supremely good for us. In all five Blue Zones of the world where ten times as many people live zestful, long lives they enjoy plenty of them.
It's simply false to suggest that all carbs are bad and we should be avoiding them, period.
It's all about the twenty year diabetes rule which we will get to lower down this page.
Few things spoil the enjoyment of our meals more than counting calories and carbs. Banish them both but do get a basic idea of what different starches do to your blood sugar. Potatoes and white rice have a very high glycemic index but that of corn on the cob is low.
Luckily new potatoes and brown rice have a low GI; still keep the glycemic load down if you are obese or diabetic. That means small portions.
You can count calories and carbs or you can turn to enjoying whole foods without guilt.
This is where it gets difficult. There's a big fat lie in milling whereby they can mislead us by labelling their flour as "whole grain" provided they do not remove more than 40% of the goodies; the bran and germ.
When you read about "wholegrain bread" you really have no idea what they are talking about. So accurate meal planning and carb counting becomes almost impossible.
So commercial bread, even the wholewheat loaf has a higher glycemic load; it will affect your blood glucose negatively. So limit yourself to no more than one or perhaps two slices per day.
Sourdough has a much lower GI but it's expensive because it takes a lot of work to bake.
The best option by far is to buy a mill and a bread-machine; bake your own sourdough loaf using 100% wholemeal flour. It takes just five minutes per day.
Stone-ground grits and steel cut oats contain all the germ and bran. They both have a low glycemic index; no detrimental effect on your blood glucose and so in the bigger picture are not fattening. But they are quite difficult to find; if it's in a box assume it has been refined.
Half a cup contains about 16 grams of carb but it is "resistant starch;" much is fibre that is not digested forming glucose but fermented in the colon by the friendly microflora.
Incidentally we strongly recommend cooking up enough for say 4 days, allowing it to cool overnight and then reheating in portions in the morning for breakfast. The starch "retrogrades" slowing the digestion by enzymes in the small intestine and helping modify any glucose spike. You will also find it does not then give you gas or abdominal discomfort.
The ketogenic diets recommend avoiding legumes because of their carbs but they also contain a lot of vegetable protein.
So you are faced with an awkward decision. Are you going to cut out the legumes from your meal planning and carb counting; and rely on meat for your protein with all the attendant risks of instead dying from a malignant tumour? Actually I don't think it is difficult at all; enjoy your beans and peas but small portions if you are obese or diabetic.
Legumes have a low glycemic index and there's massive research that they contribute to wellness; we avoid them at our peril. But do acknowledge that they have some starch and account for it in your meal planning and carb counting.
It takes just five minutes to make your own authentic hummus recipe once you are in the groove.
What will be pleasing is that returning to whole grains and legumes for your starch will dig a far smaller hole in your budget than refined carbs and meat.
Cornflakes are 15 times more expensive than grits for example; and a lot less tasty.
It will mean probably spending more money up front on certain appliances and taking time finding sources of these products.
For example you may decide to spend a moderate sum on a stone mill to grind the grain, a bread-machine and a pressure-cooker for the legumes. Consequently we bake what we somewhat arrogantly describe as the best sourdough loaf in South Africa for about half a dollar. A quick google search suggests that commercially you are looking at about 6 USD; twelve times the price.
Pressure-cooking your own chickpeas means a quarter of the price in cans; and no preservatives, salt or sugar.
Now meal planning and carb counting have become much simpler; in fact you can ignore the latter part completely.
If you have been swayed and convinced by the keto folks here again you will have some challenges. Don't just accept what I say but also be ready to question their concepts.
There is strong research that those who enjoy 7 or more coloured foods every day have about a 35% lower all-cause of death; that's massive. But you'll find many of them have a lot of carbs. Whether it is watermelon, beets or butternut you may find yourself thinking about carb counting. Perish the thought; just keep the load down. That means small portions if you are diabetic or obese.
Coloured foods are rich in the phytonutrients that are so important to your wellness. If you avoid them because of the carb content you are going to be deficient in vital substances such as beta-cryptoxanthin, lutein and tocopherols just to name three. If your meal planning is found lacking Alzheimer's disease, macular-degeneration and cardiovascular disease lurk just around the corner.
Talk to ten different doctors and you'll get 10 answers; but all will agree that one way or another you must get those pounds off if you want to live long in the land. That means for a season you will have to limit even the good carbs when meal planning.
Our simple rule of thumb is as follows.
Strong research shows that no diets work for the vast majority. After a year only 5% have actually lost weight and many have put on.
Diet is a dirty four-letter word; banish it from your thinking. They simply don't work and will frustrate the hell out of you.
When you start thinking about Bernard Preston's meal planning and carb counting, make absolutely no changes that are not sustainable for life; otherwise you are doomed to disappointment.
Can you give up commercial bread for ever? If not you are faced with two options.
If the idea of a strong and vigorous ninety plus years excites you then start thinking about creating a mini Blue Zone at your own home. It will mean some changes. Longevity does not happen by chance and it has little to do with your genes; it's mostly about lifestyle.
You will need to start growing some of your own food including broad beans, finding a source of good sourdough bread and getting most of your protein from legumes, fish and fowl.
In all five Blue Zones they independently plant and eat broad beans; old and dry they are perfectly horrid. They are the only source of dopamine, the feel-good hormone.
Dr George Campbell after studying the dietary habits of people in South Africa found that those eating large amounts of sugar and refined carbs would be fully diabetic after twenty years.
His twenty year diabetes rule should be central when meal planning and carb counting; if you have no desire to spend the second half of your life consulting doctors and taking medication.
Around 50% of Americans are either fully diabetic or well on the way.
A sweet tooth has to be strictly controlled; here you should be carb counting. Sugar, syrup and honey all contain around 5 grams per teaspoon.
One litre of most soft drinks contains about 30 teaspoons; your total daily allowance of starch. Diet-free is even worse but that's another complex story.
Interesting German research reveals that natural unprocessed honey has a low GI; no more than three teaspoons per day.
We need not be fearful of the carbs in whole grains, fruit and legumes.
Diabetics and the obese can enjoy too but small portions; and always take a short walk after a starchy meal.
The sugars in fermented foods have been converted to other substances. Natural wines, kefir and sauerkraut are excellent probiotics low in carbs.
Stop carb counting and start enjoying your food.
Meal planning and carb counting can help stabilise blood glucose. Those enjoying whole foods need not be fearful; small portions of starchy dishes.
Our newsletter is entitled "create a cyan zone" at your home, preserving both yourself, the family and friends, and Mother Earth for future generations. We promise not to spam you with daily emails promoting various products. You may get an occasional nudge to buy one of my books!
Here are the back issues.
Did you find this page interesting? How about forwarding it to a friend, or book and food junkie; or, better still, a Facebook or Twitter tick would help.
56 Groenekloof Rd,